|
|
|
Title: The Myth of Irrationality: The Science of the Mind from Plato to Star Trek
Purchase
Item
Manufacturer: Carroll & Graf Pub
List Price: $24.00
Our Price: $42.89
|
|
| Customer Reviews: |
| The Myth of Irrationality: The Science of the Mind from Plato to Star Trek by Carroll & Graf Pub Enlightenment/Post Enlightenment | Ignore the (bizarre) Kirkus review that claims that there is 'nothing new' here. In fact McCrone's claims are bold and revolutionary. The key point he makes is in the title: there is no such thing as irrationality. The corollary of this is that there is no such thing as rationality either. In fact this has been shown by work by Damasio (see his 'Descartes' Error' for details). People with brain damage to the parts of the brain which regulate emotions exhibit behaviour which seems (to us) profoundly IRrational. Therefore it is false to claim that there is such as thing as 'rationality' (meaning being unemotional or logical). Instead what we term rationality (and really, common sense would be a better word) is an emergent property of our emotional AND the logical parts of the brain.
Therefore the battle between attackers and defenders of the 'Enlightenment' is shown to be profoundly misguided: both sides were right and both sides were wrong. What both sides shared was a view of human beings as being fundamentally individuals, and that cognition is an 'internal' process.
It's a shame that the Kirkus reviewer stated that this is merely a rehash of Enlightenment psychology. Actually as McCrone makes clear, his viewpoint is fundamentally SOCIOLOGICAL. He therefore echoes philosophers and psychologists who have emphasised the social aspect of thought: Vygotsky and the later Wittgenstein.
The implications of this are rather radical.
Firstly, the view of Artificial Intelligence and 'Cognitivism' is incorrect. There is no such thing as emotionless reason, or cognition without a social context.
Secondly 'cognitivism' (and similar views: i.e. those of Fodor and Chomsky) cannot be correct. Cognitivism argues that cognition was an 'internal' process. But McCrone shows (in the case of feral children) this is false. Cognition is intrinsically external and social. The 'internal monologue' (as Vygotsky proved) developed AFTERWARDS.
Finally this is a very interesting and well written book. McCrone's other books are also excellent as is his webiste 'Neuronaut'. (www.btinternet.com/~neuronaut/) | | The Myth of Irrationality: The Science of the Mind from Plato to Star Trek by Carroll & Graf Pub This is a challenge to think. | | The nature of human consciousness would have to be about the most interesting subject around, and that is what this book concerns itself with. It is objective, honest, unemotional and is written by an intelligent educated person expressly for intelligent educated people, without being ponderous. It is the most comprehensive, accessible and sensible account of the matter to date, and I recommended it without reserve. But it has not been without critics, mostly coming from positions of vested interest and clever-than-thou qualifications. Well, I'm pretty well qualified to express opinions on neurobiology, psychiatry, psychology and anthropology which means I'm more qualified than most to comment. So I will. Essentially, there are three positions here, put with great persuasion. #1. The Enlightenment model of human consciousness, particularly in view of recent findings, is the best one available, is probably pretty close to the mark, and has been left languishing disgracefully long. Consciousness is the mainly internal use of language - any language - to construct, mobilize and initiate: memories, hopes, fears, explanations, narratives, plans, and so forth. Humans without language never develop human consciousness, they are animals. And if you doubt that read the well-documented wolf children accounts. #2. We are and do what we think, and our thinking is self-determined. We think a certain way because we choose to; we could easily think differently if we were aware that other choices existed. This is a profound point and it also introduces a very pragmatic element to the otherwise sterile and interminable free will debate. #3. Our thought patterns have been influenced, very much for the worse, by about 300 years of romantic claptrap; and to this extent we are victims of our own social history. That influence must be faced up to, recognized for what it is, and assigned to the trashcan when appropriate. This is where McCrone really makes enemies. He cold-bloodedly rubbishes virtually all of contemporary psychology and absolutely all of the psychoanalytic movement. This is a man worthy of respect and support. These are wretchedly muddled times screaming out for for rational thought and action. Don't wait for other people to set an example. If you want to purge your brain of all sorts of nonsense and start feeling and acting like a rational human being then put this book next to Dr D D Burns' "Feeling Good" and refer to both frequently. They share that tragically scarce commodity - common sense. | | The Myth of Irrationality: The Science of the Mind from Plato to Star Trek by Carroll & Graf Pub Right or wrong completely absorbing. | | In spite of an ongoing interest in various aspects of psychotherapy and spiritual practice I am a novice with regard to the biology of consciousness and as such I found this book difficult to set down once I started reading. I suspect that there is much to criticize in it. Many questions come up that need to be considered at length. Still, if you don't know much about the brain itelf and how it functions this book is an fascinating place to start learning about it. |
Launching AppleScripts with Keyboard Shortcuts
Jochen Walters, MacDevCenter.com: “AppleScript automation is one of OS X’s most useful features. It lets you automate common, repetitive tasks so you can spend your time on more important things. Some AppleScripts would be even more useful, and their usage more seamless, if you could launch them by just hitting a key combination. And you can.”
Sat, 09 Jun 2007 04:22:58 GMT
|
Replacing AppleScript with Ruby
Matt Neuburg, MacDevCenter.com: “I’ll explain how to download and install rb-appscript. I’ll discuss the basics of rb-appscript usage and show how to develop a simple ‘hello world’ script. Finally, I’ll rewrite the Ruby-AppleScript example from my book to use Ruby with rb-appscript instead.”
Tue, 27 Feb 2007 18:29:46 GMT
|
How to Write a Cocoa Web Server
Jürgen Schweizer, MacDevCenter.com: “A couple of weeks ago a friend asked me to write a Mac-based HTTP server for an intranet web service he was building. I hadn’t forgotten how Mac OS X was praised because of its Unix underpinnings, and the strong networking capabilities that come along with that. As a Cocoa developer, I was confident that I could find a nice Cocoa API that would do the hard work for me, so I accepted...”
Wed, 15 Nov 2006 00:39:57 GMT
|
Getting Started with Quartz Composer
Erica Sadun, MacDevCenter.com: “Take Quartz Composer, for example. It’s a free utility that can bring new life and interest to your iMovie projects. In this article, you’ll learn how to use your own pictures to create a simple but flashy animation.”
Fri, 24 Mar 2006 18:05:02 GMT
|
The Power of mdfind
MacDevCenter.com, Andy Lester: “I had the power of Spotlight available to me from the Unix shell. Experienced Unix users will find mdfind’s interface familiar. Mac power users who have never used the Unix under the hood of Tiger are in for a treat.”
Thu, 05 Jan 2006 01:52:36 GMT
|
A Quick Look at the MarsEdit Weblog Editor
Derrick Story, O’Reilly: “It sports a clean UI that you’d expect from Ranchero (feeling very NetNewsWire like), is very easy to connect to your MT server, enables roundtrip editing in your favorite text editor (in addition to its own friendly editor interface), has easy-to-use image uploading (uses a separate window that also catalogs your previous image uploads for easy repurposing), includes an RPC console, and is AppleScriptable.”
Sat, 31 Dec 2005 18:51:12 GMT
|
Managing MySQL on Mac OS X
O’Reilly, Robert Daeley: “MySQL is a popular database management system with which most web developers are familiar. You can’t swing a cat on the internet without hitting a website running it on the back end.”
Thu, 15 Dec 2005 18:22:23 GMT
|
Model-View-Controller in Web 2.0
O’Reilly, Fraser Speirs: “In the Web 2.0 apps that really Get It, they have a database backend, a web frontend and—crucially—some kind of web services API in between. Flickr is a great example of this kind of architecture—almost everything you can do through the Flickr website can be done programmatically through a desktop application.”
Mon, 10 Oct 2005 23:32:30 GMT
|
What Is Darwin (and How It Powers Mac OS X)
MacDevCenter.com: “Darwin is the Unix-derived core that provides the underlying foundation for Mac OS X. At Darwin’s heart is the XNU kernel—a Mach 3.0-based microkernel that has been modified to include portions of FreeBSD for performance reasons.”
Sat, 01 Oct 2005 18:01:38 GMT
|
Fundraiser auction: get cool software for a good cause
Seth Dillingham’s PMC Software Auctions are now live. The disks being auctioned have incredible applications: BBEdit, Delicious Library, FlySketch, OmniOutliner, and tons more. (We at Ranchero donated copies of NetNewsWire and MarsEdit.) Check out the entire list.
There are great Windows disks too, with apps like FeedDemon, Lux, Onfolio Professional, and TopStyle. (And more.)
Fri, 30 Sep 2005 15:11:55 GMT
|
Web Apps with Tiger: Getting Started
Kevin Hemenway: MacDevCenter.com: “Yeah, yeah, yeah. You’ve got your Dashboard, your Automator, your Spotlight, your uber-Safari, and your RSS screensaver. And they’re great, dandy, zippidity-doo-dah. It’d be terrific if there were something new under the hood for web serving, right?”
Wed, 17 Aug 2005 19:00:02 GMT
|
Write Your Own Automator Actions
MacDevCenter.com, Matt Neuburg: “An Automator Action is extremely easy to write. Documentation on how to do so is copious and helpful... Still, all that documentation may seem overwhelming at first, so this article presents a simple hands-on example to get you started down the road to writing your own Actions.”
Wed, 04 May 2005 17:46:25 GMT
|
The birth of a new app
O’Reilly, Giles Turnbull: “Enter Sam DeVore, full-time dad and part-time programmer. He saw the need for something new, and suspected he could create it very rapidly. He posted to the list, announcing his plan, and set to work.”
Mon, 04 Apr 2005 17:14:38 GMT
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
